Scott, a mild-mannered gay writer in Los Angeles, gets wrapped up into a world of bad boys and their crime-filled past after being adopted as their “Daddy Scott”, whether he likes it or not.
Realizing his daughter's first date is about to be with a bad boy, Scott sits him down for a pre-date interview. But all is not what it seems.
Tired of hiding who he really is, Mack wants to come out to Scott. But neither get what they were expecting.
Mack gets his "Daddy Scott" to pretend to be his real dad when a probation officer comes for a check in. But Scott gets more than he bargained for.
After learning Mack loves "Gilmore Girls", Scott surprises him with his "Gilmore"-starring neighbor. But it doesn't go as he expects.
Scott has a holiday dinner with Mack’s mom and brother, and discovers they may not have left their bad ways behind.
Scott helps BJ figure out if he’s doing porn – with unexpected results.
Scott is visited by an unexpected delivery boy, to whom his agent takes a liking.
Scott tries to keep Jim and BJ away while anticipating the arrival of a date.
Scott helps Jim and his lawyer write a witness statement, but soon realizes things didn’t go as they say.
While at the LGBT Center, Scott’s session with his counselor is unexpectedly crashed by some familiar faces in need of help of their own.
Jim decides to take care of Scott when he feels ill but might end up killing him in the process.
BJ hosts the reading of Paul Jomas's will at Scott's place, but an unexpected revelation leads everyone to wonder who might have killed him.
Jim and BJ each try to convince Scott's agent to make a movie about their life, leading to an epic lap dance-off where winner takes all.
Scott tries to help Jim pay tribute to his dad, but ends up getting confronted with issues of his own.
Scott tries to convince Whitney that her visiting sister is actually an FBI agent trying to frame him for murder.
After Scott's night falls apart, Jim imagines alternate realities to show Scott how his choices aren't always the right ones.
Surprise visits from a director and an agent lead to big opportunities for BJ's career, but their motives may not be what he thinks.
Jim wants to give Scott a reward massage for finishing his script, but unexpected interruptions get in the way.
Scott's script sparks the interest of a producer just as he learns some unsettling news.
Scott's relaxing getaway becomes anxiety-ridden when he realizes that someone could be lurking anywhere, waiting to kill him.
Scott’s catered lunch with Brian goes off track when an unexpected waiter shows up.
Scott is pulled over on his way to a production meeting, leading to new revelations about who might be trying to kill him.
A game night with the boys threatens to get derailed by Jim’s mistrust of Brian - and mysterious happenings around the house.
Calista uses multiple tactics - and a bottle of whiskey - to get Scott to confess to his role in Paul Jomas’s murder.