Olaf "Gunn" Gunnunderson, an out-and-proud gay college student, crawls back into the closet to survive the holidays with his parents. He keeps his cool as his quirky Midwestern hale and hearty parents try to set him up with his high school sweetheart, Abby. But when his boyfriend, Nathan, shows up unannounced, Gunn must put on a charade to keep the relationship a secret.