Martin and Ted get unwanted advice from Val and Eddie as they each get ready to go to a Yankees game. Eddie and Val discuss looking for a new place to live. Benny invites Martin and Ted to an art exhibit.
Martin and Ted bond at a gallery exhibit. Val and Eddie have a disagreement over vaginas and Benny lends some helpful insight.
Benny shows Eddie and Val a high-rise apartment a bit out of their price range. Ted wants advice on a thank you gift for Martin. Eddie is less than happy about Ted's "transformation" but Benny hatches a plan to bring peace.
The gang gathers for dinner with a few unexpected guests. Ted worries about how his father will react to his friendships with Martin and. Ted's neighbor Glen is confused about Ted's living situation.